Although development leads to the need for clean, potable water,
sometimes the search for that water gets in the way of development.
Plans for the South Antrim Business Center may change and less
land may be available for development due to the hunt for water.
"Efforts are being made by the water authority (Greencastle Area,
Franklin County, Water Authority) to seek a well site on the Gayman
property," Scott Diffenderfer, chairman of the Antrim Township Board
of Supervisors, told members of the Greencastle-Antrim Council of
Governments on Tuesday.
The group, consisting of representatives from Greencastle-Antrim
school board, the borough and the township, have been meeting since
December to work toward attracting commercial growth to the area
while controlling residential development.
Some Greencastle and Antrim Township officials said that plans to
drill a well on the Gayman property could jeopardize plans for
completion of the connector road and the business park.
The Gayman property, owned by Harold Gayman, covers most of Phase
2 of the connector road. The road is needed to optimize South Antrim
Business Center — a proposed 435-acre property with mixed zoning
that includes light industrial, highway commercial, professional and
community commercial — and would run from Leitersburg Pike to U.S.
11, according to Gary Gembe, president of the Greencastle-Antrim
Area Development Corp.
In an effort to attract businesses to the area, Antrim Township
embarked on Phase 1 of a connector road project that would connect
the area north of Pa. 16 with Leitersburg Pike. The infrastructure
of Phase 1 — the road with water and sewer lines — has been
completed. Once phases 1 and 2 are completed, the connector road
project will connect exits 3 and 5 of Interstate 81.
Diffenderfer said that Evon Barvinchack, chairman of the water
authority, told the council of governments at March's meeting that
he wouldn't look for water on the Gayman property.
"The municipal water authority said, 'If you don't want us to go
there, we won't go there,'" Diffenderfer said. "The next thing we
know, they're going there. I can't understand that."
"I don't remember saying, 'We're not going to develop the Gayman
land,'" said Barvinchack when contacted by phone Tuesday evening.
He said fracture trace analysis and geophysical analysis has been
conducted on five sites, including the Gayman tract, G-A school
property, Tayamentasachta Environmental Cen-
ter and areas north and south of Pa. 16 — and the Gayman tract
has the greatest potential for the highest well yield.
"This community is exploding and water demand is exploding with
it. We're looking down the road and what the demand is going to be
in 10 years," Barvinchack said. "If they develop Phase 2, where is
all this water going to come from?
"It's the old story: We want development. We want water, but
don't go in our back yard," Barvinchack said.
So far, no test wells have been drilled on the Gayman tract.
Barvinchack doesn't see how drilling on the land will put the
connector road in jeopardy.
"If we buy several acres to protect the well and put in a nice
park, how does that negatively impact their development? I think
they are being shortsighted on this," Barvinchack said. "If you want
to develop something, you're going to need water and water is where
you find it. And one plot of ground is not going to make or break
this park financially."
But, Gembe said the area is going to lose earned income tax
revenue if land for the well is taken out of prime commercial land.
"We're trying to work with them, but they have to come off the
dead center of no," Barvinchack said. "How many communities around
here have a moratorium on water usage? We're trying to be proactive
and not get into a position where we have moratoriums."
Hal Myers, Greencastle-Antrim school board member, suggested
looking at other areas for water and staying away from the connector
road.
"I'll assure you there's water out there," he said.
"We need water, but we don't need this well disrupting
development," said G-A school board president Ronald Troskoski. "We
all need to cooperate together."
"I think the township has invested its share to this connector
road by putting Phase 1 on line. We want to keep it moving,"
Diffenderfer said. "If Phase 2 doesn't happen, what's going to
happen when Phase 1 is built out? All that traffic is going to hit
Leitersburg Street and come right by the school. That's the last
thing we want to happen."
Originally published June 22, 2005